Chandri MacLeod (chandri) wrote,
Chandri MacLeod
chandri

  • Mood:

Flotter and Treebus and the Extremely Subtle Educational Material

I love the idea of Flotter and Treebus. It occurs to me that although Trek is sometimes lacking in showing that yes, people four hundred years in the future are going to have different personalities, different vocabularies, and different priorities than we do - with the exception of DS9, which was probably the best example of what Federation socialization is like - they succeeded best, I think, when they had child characters. I mean, hell - Voyager was the worst for using 20th-century vocabulary (idioms, metaphors, things that people in the 24th century shouldn't, realistically, utilize), and yet there was Naomi. At four or five the kid is studying botany and cell biology.

Kids are smarter in the 24th century. Federation kids start schooling at somewhere around two, if you believe the Primary Care classrooms on the Enterprise D. And Jake Sisko is the least 20th-century-like of all the characters on DS9. With the exception of an affinity for baseball, he's as unlike a 20th-century sitcom character as can be. They worked really hard at that "We're a Different Culture, Damnit" thing on DS9, probably a lot harder than the others, mostly because there was so much political storytelling and there were a few dozen humans surrounded by aliens in an alien setting, so distinguishing the human culture from the surrounding one was important. I loved Jake. Jake needs more show. ;)

The DS9 characters were also the least Americanized humans of all the trek shows. Which I think was important given that the first "World Government" Earth had (which was only really referenced once, I think in Next Gen) was obviously *not* centred on the U.S., whether or not Zephram Cochrane was an American, or close to, and First Contact happened in... Wyoming? Montana? Somewhere in the middle. The Federation is not an American instrument. It is, in fact, thoroughly, albeit somewhat naively, socialist. No money, no poverty, everyone at least on Earth guided to do what they want to do and are best at doing, and never mind utilitarianism.

Although to watch Enterprise, you'd never know it. They are *very* 20th-century, which is one of the many, many things about ENT that bugs the crap out of me.

I really, really want more Trek in the 24th century. Gimme. >.
Subscribe

  • (no subject)

    I just found out that one of the three other people who applied for my position (the one that was created as permanent specifically to keep me on) -…

  • (no subject)

    Okay. Okay. We have signed a lease on the new place. I have written the end-of-tenancy letter, and a thank-you note to our current (very lovely)…

  • Bike to Work Week 2013 Day 4

    STILL NOT DEAD didn't get off bike to walk up any hills today still hate hills, hills are assholes also hello shoulder pain, I remember…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment